Summer Heats Up: Summer 2008 Anime Guide

It seems like an interesting summer season. I am looking forward to a few familiar faces and I am intrigued by some of the shows coming out. I am curious to see what little gems are coming out what no one has been taking about. There are a ton of new shows coming out so we only have so much time to watch what we can so we have to be selective. We are not reviewing sequels, ongoing shows, or any show we are 99% sure we will not like. And be aware we are reviewing these shows after watching just one or two episodes, so it is just first impressions.

Birdy the Mighty Decode
birdy, mighty, decode, patlabor, aliens, Tsutomu

I have to say I was shocked to see Birdy the Mighty getting any sort of continuation. I remember the original OVA fondly though I would like to watch it again since that was ages ago. However, you don’t need to see that since this show starts at the beginning. Birdy is a butt-kicking agent for the Space Federation but when she comes to Earth she accidentally kills a human, Tsutomu. The only way to keep him alive is by combining their bodies. Tsutomu is calm and quite and Birdy is loud and out of control. The show is light space action, hinting at an overall plot, and comedy. It doesn’t seem overly perverted (which is very easily where a show like this could go) so I hope it stays that way. It is a fun show and entertaining but not by any stretch of the imagination an amazing new show.

The original Birdy the Mighty is a curiosity to me. I never saw it but it seemed like one of those shows that was always for rent at any video store with an anime section in it. So I have always been aware of the series but I have oddly enough never seen it. If nothing else this show is very 90s in it’s style. The animation is clearly modern but I feel the direction and the story is more a throw back to the 90s. I think this show is best for fans of the original or anyone who likes that time periods style of action anime. It’s definitely a fun show and I will continue to watch it is as a fun and light 90s action show with a slight nod to modern style aesthetics.

Yakushiji Ryoko no Kaiki Jikenbo
Ryoko, mystery, detective, sexy, supernatural

I did not realize that this was a supernatural detective series until I looked up the translation of the title shortly before I watched the anime. It seems like a police drama where the two detectives solve cases with a supernatural twist. Apparently Ryoko is the person to go to in the police department when you want a case solved that deals with the unexplainable. Ryoko and her partner Izumi seem to have master servant relationship with Ryoko clearly being in charge but I am glad to see that they both seem equally competent in detective work and being able to protect themselves. She also seems to have a rival on the force with a similar relationship to her partner. I think this is the show this season for people who want a more adult mystery anime.

This show melds detective with a mature, sexy woman. While I thought it had some pacing issues, it overall kept a quick transition. I liked how we are dropped into the story knowing that our duo have been working supernatural cases for a while. It does seem that the unknown is combined with hard evidence. Ryouko’s eccentricities are cause for humor and awe as she drags her faithful assistant around the city in search of clues and shopping!

Here is Greenwood (Live Action)
greenwood, ikemen, high school, crossdressing, dorm

If you don’t love Here is Greenwood, then you haven’t haven’t read the manga or watched the OVA! And here it is in a new form, live action. I think this is a show that you will love if you already know the show, but I would recommend jumping in with the earlier renditions if you’ve never experienced it before. It has the antics and comedy prevalent in Greenwood. The show establishes the personalities of our four main guys quickly and efficiently. It also has a dorm full of cute guys! And this particular time slot in Japan touts half hour episodes.

I remember Here is Greenwood fondly for several reasons. Most important being it’s the first shojo anime I ever saw. This seems a particularly accurate and faithful live action adaptation of the manga. They have a good deal of the scenes that stand out in my mind including the first time with meet the motorcycle otaku carrying around his bike, or when we first meet Kazuya’s sister-in-law, or when we discover Shun’s secret. Speaking of Shun’s secret I know that it is hard to find a guy who can act and still pass for a woman when cross dressing and I think they do a satisfactory but flawed job in their casting. The actor they got was decent but it some scenes and looks like a girl but in other scenes he is quite obviously a man in drag. I am curious to see which storylines from the manga they adapt, to see how funny “Here is Devilwood” is, and to see the last story line’s adaptation.

Antique Bakery
yaoi, BL, antique, bakery, cake, pastry

Antique Bakery is a slice of life show about four men running a bakery. This show is a healing anime with a gay character in it but many people feel that this is very light BL show. I don’t think that just because a BL author writes something with a gay character in it’s not automatically BL. Gay characters are valid characters in shows outside of BL. Antique Bakery reminds me of The Bartender with a pastry shop instead of a bar. The basic formula seems to be that a customer comes into the shop and through interacting with the employees comes to solve some problem in their life. These types of shows are made for people who want to come home after a hard day of work and see an uplifting, calm tale with some pastry porn on the side. There seems to be an overarching plot about the owner’s kidnapping as a child but it is mainly meant to be an episodic show.

I really loved the way the opening was done, just something fun and different. It has an easy pace, could be very sitcom like. But overall it just didn’t grab me in any way. There is nothing innately wrong with it but it certainly doesn’t have a hook like normal shows. Everything seems to move in a subdued manner, but that seems to be the idea.

Chocolate Underground
chocolate, underground, bootleg, Alex Shearer

Wow, so these episodes are short but not definite lengths, some were around 3 minutes while another was almost 5. But they have been able to make me curious is that short span. These two kids live in a crazy place where chocolate had been outlawed (along with anything else that is bad for you). But rumor has it there are chocolate bootleggers with secret stores of chocolate. That certainly peaked their interests and they set off to find it. I love the sense of adventure and mystery found in young adult literature! This series felt serious and fun at the same time. And look at those two boys. Aren’t they adorable? And their shared crush on the girl at the bakery is very cute, too. I will be watching.

Chocolate Underground is based on the British novel Bootleg by Alex Shearer. Chocolate Underground is an ONA that means it is an anime primarily released on the Internet. It’s not the first ONA but it is the first I have watched. Overall it’s rather cute. The episodes are rather well paced fro being so short. Each one feels like a chapter from a book. Which might actually be the case. I feel opening scene with the special forces team with the armored mech to bust a couple eating chocolate in their home is rather extreme. The whole chocolate ban is a deft social commentary in a rather sweet coating.

Slayers Revolution
slayers, lina, gourry, zelgadis, amelia, revolution

This had to be the biggest surprise of the year! New Slayers? Don’t lie to me.I couldn’t believe it. Though I think there is a whole generation of fans that have not watched Slayers, so I wonder what their reaction to the series will be. The relationships between characters is already established so it could throw off first timers. However, I was delighted, everything was harkening back to the original. Even the way the title of the episode was introduced.

Look. It’s very simple. Give me more Zelgadis and Amelia in generous amounts and I am generally sold on your show. I’m sure that otaku are happy for the return of Megumi Hayashibara as Lina if nothing else. And I think that old school Slayers fans will be happy. This was not made for new viewers. There is little to no effort made to get people up to speed. You are assumed to know and love these characters and are just waiting to see what trouble they are going to find themselves in next. Overall it’s an excellent return to the Slayers formula. There is the trademark humor in full force and a decent amount of action as well. Everyone is in perfect form. As long as they don’t mess up like they did with the end of Slayers Try this should be fun.

Natsume Yuujinchou
natsume, yuujinchou, ayakashi, lucky cat

The one line pitch for Natsume Yuujinchou would be XXXholic meets Mushishi. We have a young man who can see spirits but does not want to who is takes up the mantle of dealing with the wide variety of local spirits. Natsume’s relationship with his spirit cat friend seems slightly odd but interesting enough that I want to see how it develops. So far the spirits presented have not been too dangerous but there have been hints that this will not always be the case. The cat spirit has a powerful form reminiscent of Amaterasu from Oakmi so I assume he will be the muscle. I am curious if Natsume will ever get any combat power or will he continue to use his wits to solve his problems. Natsume’s grandmother reminds me of Tohru Honda’s mom which means she is the selling point for this series. ;-)

It seems like every season there is one show that emotionally hooks me in the first episode. This time around it was Natsume Yuujinchou. Sometimes I can’t quite put my finger on how they did it. All I know is that I was really sad to hear the story of that Ayakashi. I am curious to see how all the names made it into the book. And I also laughed a whole lot, the cat is too funny! And I love his voice. Enjoyable first episode and I will be getting the next as soon as possible.

Blade of the Immortal
blade, manji, ren, anotsu, immortal, samurai

It is dangerous to have high hopes sometimes. I have been a BotI fan since it first started coming out in English, I never thought it would ever become an anime. Hiroki Samura’s art style is very complex and sketchy so I wasn’t sure how it was going to translate on screen. But lo and behold everyone looks like themselves just super smooth. The first episode is basically faithful to the first chapter with the addition of showing a little of Ren and oddly adding in Hyakurin who doesn’t show up till much later. But I can appreciate them trying to get all the major players established considering the time restraints. The fight at the end was not anything special unfortunately, though I think it still serves the purpose of showing Maji is a crazy bad-ass. But I thought this could be a moment to shine and really show this series is full of messed up stuff and people getting chopped in two. They did have, what becomes sort of iconic in the manga, Manji carrying around his lost limbs though. The opening was also really adult and intense, very nice. That what the show needs to be. I think I’ll have to watch a few more to really decide if it is going in a good direction.

The manga of Blade of the Immortal has a very distinct art style. So much in fact that the rumor was that the author never let the series be animated before this because he never felt anyone could capture the unique artistry of his manga. The character designs are simplified from the manga but I don’t think that you could ever get the budget to animate Blade of the Immortal’s original character designs on a TV budget. They even go out of their way to reproduce the elaborate death portraits important characters get when they die from the original manga. It looks like they are going out of their way to capture the mature feeling of the manga which will definitely help sell this in the American market. Kagimura Habaki and Kagehisa Anotsu also appear earlier than they appear in the manga as well. It is an odd choice to have certain characters show up so early but I can’t really I really fault them for it. The choice that perplexed me the most was the random modern city imagery in the opening, closing, and eyes catches quite bizarre since the story takes place around 1782. I know people are going to take this show to town because it’s animated by Bee Train but other than the Bee Train signature of having an extremely in your face back background music score everything seems fine. I will reserve my final judgment for a few more episodes but so far it gets my thumbs up.

Shibatora (Live Action)
shibatora, koike, teppei, police, shinigami, detective

I was originally looking into this show because Koike Teppei is the star! If you have seen the Lovely Complex movie, you might recognize him. Anyway, I think he is a very cute and playful actor. This show is based on a manga by the same name, it combines comedy with drama and a bit of a sentimental element. Shibatora is working to be a detective but he has a naive and innocent face and sports some mad Kendo skills. It has a long list of wacky characters that add to Shibatora’s mostly serious personality. The show overall was fun and pulled me into the characters. Though there are moments that seemed off pace. Like during the dramatic climax there is a comedic moment but it was not seemlessly done, in fact I was laughing from it’s odd placement. And also Shibatora’s ability to sense when death is near seems frivolous and pointless, luckily this doesn’t come up too often. Lastly, the theme is done by Every Little Thing which is totally awesome!

Shibatora seems like a fun show in which the editor made the author throw in the supernatural part for no particular reason. It seems to be there to get him involved with the characters but he already has a reason to be trying to help people. He is a cop. It might be a good hook if Shibatora was not a detective but it just seems tacked on. I might also call it lazy story telling but Shibatora always has to do detective work after he gets a psychic insight. It’s never simply a case of deus ex machina. Other than that it is a fun Japanese cop drama. Shibatora and his friends at the clothing shop have a fun dynamic and Shibatora is a cute likeable character. I also really loved that his boss has a office in the middle of the basement. I want a secret base in the police department, too. They seem to really like to beat up poor Shibatora because he gets quite a bit of damage done to him during this episode.

World Destruction
world, destruction, RPG, furries, video, game

This is an anime based on a video game (or rather they are both coming out at once) and therefore it stinks and therefore I am going to be snarky for the rest of this preview. Sufficed to say it’s not worth your time unless you are a furry. A furry with no taste. In a world where adorable looking beastmen rule over humans one boy heroically dons cheap cosplay cat ears to find work. In a world where one crazy psycho girl wants to destroy everyone and seems to have an all too easy time convincing other people to commit mass suicide with her and take along everyone else while they are at it. In a world where they attempt to make the love child of Snake Pliskin and Teddy Ruxpin a bad ass and noble hero. This is the world of World Destruction. I say they can’t destroy this world quick enough.

This show tried to cram every type of character we have seen in a RPG into one show and it was a big mess. It was obviously supposed to combine humor and drama but it seemed to not hit either. The funniest thing about the show was everything that was wrong with it, from the poor animation (this is the first episode people! We shouldn’t see the C team come in yet) to the badly thoughtout story. The dramatic scene that was supposed to bring us on board, to have the two characters start to understand each other, to get us intrigued…fell flat. In my opinion, nothing went right in this show. Oh, wait, I did like the closing song but maybe that was because I was so glad it was over.

Telepathy Shoujo Ran
shoujo, telepathy, ran, psychic, girls, magical

Why are these people using their psychic powers will-nilly in school? This series was not very stimulating. I am having a hard time putting words to it. It was just there, it wasn’t bad, it wasn’t anything. I feel as though I will forget I have even watched it just as I kept forgetting the name of it the other day.

While it was certainly not my favorite show of the season, I think I certainly liked this one more than Narutaki. It sort of a standard magical girl show. Ran does not transform but she has broad array of psychic powers including telepathy. There is a transfer student who has the same powers she does and keeps trying to get her to use her power and convince her that they are monsters who no one else will accept. Midori, the transfer student seems like she will go from be an antagonist to an ally in the great shonen tradition despite the fact that this is a shoujo show. There also seems to be a greater band of evil people with psychic powers to be the big bad guys.

Nogizaka Haruka no Himitsu
nogizaka, haruka, otaku, moe, secret

Sometimes it takes a hero to jump on a live grenade to save the rest of the platoon. Other times it just takes a fool. Well, I jumped only to find out it was a dud. Narutaki and I were assuming this show was going to be deathly bad and I secretly hoped that it might be good. It turns out it’s really just plain. Yuto, an average guy finds out that Haruka, the most popular girl in school, is secretly an otaku. This leads to them becoming friends. If Yuto or Haruka were really interesting it might have sold me on this show but they are both very average. Yuto seems to have some fight in him to complain out loud but not enough to stop anyone from tormenting him. Haruka is just a princess girl that happens to like anime. She is hardly moe enough to dislike but not cool enough to love. I guess I was secretly hoping for a Nagi-like character. The only thing that stuck out that would be really bad is that he lives with his sister and one of his teachers from school. When Yuto is at home they bully him into serving them snacks and booze. They are clearly there for A. fan-service shots; B. “jokes”; and C. to make problems and misunderstandings between Yuto and Haruka later on.

Yasuko to Kenji (Live Action)
yasuko, kenji, manga-ka, gangs, shojo

This show is a well done combo of comedy mixed with a sentimental first romance and family issues. Kenji is a ex-gang leader trying to raise his little sister, Yasuko, who is now in high school. The best way he found to do this was his talent for writing shojo manga! Kenji is now a well established manga-ka. His actual identity is a secret. If this isn’t a perfect combination for comedy gold, well then nothing is. This show is over the top funny as Yasuko butts heads with Kenji, who is super overprotective, and also starts to live out a bit of shojo manga herself with the new guy at school. Of course the show wouldn’t be complete with out some sort of gang fight!

This is the one live action show I truly regret not being able to watch subtitled. I’m sure this already hysterical show would be even better with me being able to fully understand the dialog. Kenji’s bad ass demeanor mixed with the scenes of him writing his ultra flowery shojo comics is just priceless. I also like Kenji and Yasuko’s back and forth battles for who is in charge of her life. I know that his two assistants were former members of his gang but I’m curious how they wound up working for him. I liked Yasuko’s love interest, Tsubaki, but his family is even better. Also the fight scenes were so manga styled. It was a nice adaptation. For some reason they really like to have poor Yasuko fall on her face. I’m not saying it’s not funny but you have to feel bad for the poor girl. I think I’m going to try to tract down the original manga because this looks like a winner but no one seems to be scanlating it. Hopefully a American manga company will pick this one up.

I would like to make two observations about Japanese live actions shows before we go. The first is cake is everywhere. In all the live action shows we watched someone always got cake whenever they went over to someone’s house. No wonder Tachibana went into the pastry business. According to Japanese drama people in Japan eat cake like three times a day. That and it seems to me that the background music is very noticeable in Japanese dramas. Is it just me or do any other our readers notice the same thing?

The cake industry in Japan must be booming! Any how, this is a rare season where I actually knew things about the upcoming shows (weather I’ve read the manga, know the actors, or know the previous series) and I had different expectations. This season is also full of surprises with series I never thought I would see made. It is quite exciting! And of course minus all the stuff I knew about, there are some great gems that I had no inkling what they were. Such is the great thing about plopping down and watching a whole ton of shows.

//

Ongoing Investigations: Case #001

I have been eating up Daughter of Twenty Faces every week. I anxiously await the next episode and I love that feeling. I was really happy to hear DoTF was given a 26 episode run after initially having only 13. Being a lover of detective fiction, it is not hard to imagine me glomming onto this show. However, the show is also really good! Albeit over the top but I think that is what is so exciting, it wraps all things detective into it but still manages to surprise you. Episodes nine and ten start to establish some of the stuff we see in the opening and ending. I have a bit of theory and am curious if it is true. Detective stories constantly have red herrings so it’ll be interesting to see this play out.

Finally watched the last episode of Tower of Druaga. I have to say, this series turned out to be pretty good. Finally some decent fantasy anime. I was glad we didn’t get some huge information dump in this last episode, just the end of an arc. I am definitely looking forward to the next season. And it was a good experiment by Gonzo, the whole coming out at the same time as the Japanese. I was really happy with the results.

Watched the finale of Zettai Kareshi (Absolute Boyfriend). This live action comedy/drama is loosely based on the Yuu Watase work of the same name. With all the changes that were made to the story I was surprised, pleasantly, how close the ending came to the original as far as feelings. I was unhappy with a few of the middle episodes, but I liked the approach they took of showing Night becoming human (and Riko realizing it) slowly where in the manga I never really thought of him as anything but. Overall, it’s a cute series for women.

I watched the American live action Fist of the North Star movie. It is mostly a retelling of the first part of Hokuto no Ken, Kenshiro’s fight with Shin. It is definitely a silly movie but it really seems that it wants to reproduce what makes Hokuto no Ken such a popular franchise world wide. Lots of the story details are correct but it seems to miss the spirit overall. It does not help that when ever Kenshiro does his signature moves they come off more silly than fearsome. It’s oddly enough a fun movie if you just want a cheesy martial arts film but a blasphemy if you want the definitive live action Hokuto no Ken.

Also watched the last four episodes of Sexy Voice and Robo another live action comedy/drama. It is also loosely based on an unfinished seinen manga. I originally picked this up because Kenichi Matsuyama plays Robo, you may know him as L. Sexy Voice and Robo investigate weird occurrences but they always end up helping people. It was a lot of fun but also always had a little moral or something in it. It has a hopeful vibe and Niko (Sexy Voice) our 14-year-old protagonist can sometimes be profound.

I watched all of Karin recently. I was in the mood for a light romantic comedy and Karin fit the bill. It’s definitely a shonen romance series, but I can see why it has found a fan following among girls in the U.S. If you add in vampires to anything you have to go out of your way to turn off girls. It can be done but you have to try pretty hard. I am looking at you Rosario + Vampire. I liked Karin and Kenta and the rest of the side cast was amusing. Karin being a blood making vampire is certainly inventive as well. I like how vampires work in the Karin universe. The fact that vampires in Karin drain emotions along with blood is a novel approach to the vampire mythos while still being conducive for comedy. The only thing I have to bringing up is that the vampire hunter’s costumes in this series have to be the goofiest thing on Gackt Camui’s green earth. I know this is a comedy but seriously.

Read the first book of Goong, a very popular manhwa. A prince has to marry a commoner who his grandfather made a promise to. Neither of them are too happy with the idea. Can’t say I’m all that impressed as of yet but it has left me curious enough to pick up atleast the next volume. It has potential. Though no one really captured my attention. The art is only great on occasion, though I know it is long running so that can change. I have been on a shojo romance hiatus for a while so maybe I just wasn’t ready for another foray yet.

I just read book ten of Eden: It’s an Endless World! and Hiroki Endo is more than willing to kill off characters. Every time I think that a character can’t be killed, Hiroki Endo proves me wrong and murders them in epic fashion. Hiroki Endo is also a genius because he will often put a character in several near fatal situations and have them pull though before ultimately killing them. This means you never know if a character is just in a tight situation or they going to meet their maker. All too often you are not worried about characters because you have a good idea of who is going to live and who is going to die. Eden makes sure every book is tense because you have no guarantees anyone lives. I highly recommend everyone try this series because it’s not doing that well but it should be. It’s a gritty cyberpunk series with a good mix of action, sex, and gnostic symbolisms. It should be flying off the shelves.

Picked up Final Fantasy Tactics Advanced 2 and have barely put it down. I loved the original so I am glad to have more with a bit of an updated system, new races, and some new jobs. The laws don’t have the crazy consequences of the first and also as long as you play within the law your clan gets different bonuses. Oh and for anyone that thought the first game was too easy, this one has a difficulty setting. Haven’t gotten into the plot much yet, got sucked into the Ivalice world and am now looking for a mage to help me figure out how to get home. Not sure if I love the main character yet ( I love you Marche!) but I don’t by any means dislike him. And Adelle is nowhere near as cool as Ritz. I am hoping these characters grow on me.

That’s it for this week’s investigation. Look for new ongoing investigations every Friday!

//

Gosick Novel #01, Super loli detective!

I am always on the search for good detective anime and manga, actually I’m always on the search for good detective anything. So when I happened by this book at the store, I couldn’t resist, even knowing nothing about it. We here at Reverse Thieves will always take the time to check out a new detective related work.

I have to admit that I was mostly intrigued by the way that Narutaki described the main character and the way she looked on the cover. That and it is always nice to see light novels that are not based on licensed anime and manga. Although they just started to write a manga in Monthly Dragon Age based on the novels it’s still unlicensed in the U.S.

Gosick is the story of Kazuya Kujo and Victorique a rather unlikely detective duo. Kazuya Kujo is the youngest Japanese son of a military family sent to Europe to study. Victorique is a reclusive genius. After Victorique effortlessly solves the mysterious murder of a fortuneteller that has baffled the police, she gets an invitation for a cruise intended for the deceased. Kazuya and Victorique decide to go in the victim’s place and wind up fighting for their lives as they try to piece together who (and why) is trying to kill everyone on the ship.

I really like the setting of this series, though I’m still not sure why the author chose to create a new country in Europe rather than just using, say Switzerland. But in any case the early 20th century feel adds some meat and just seems so much more rich than a modern era. This also helped to put me in the mind set of Sherlock Holmes and Poirot.

Kazuya is an outcast as his European dominant school but he is determined to prove himself. He has a quite and sweet exterior and certainly some naiveté mixed in. He has been given the task of bringing the mysterious Victorique her daily assignments since she never shows up for class, this also makes him a bit of an enigma in the school since most people have never met her. He has a protective side, when it comes to Victorique, that comes from his soldier’s son background. Kazuya can never quite grasp the mindset of the lovely Victorique but that doesn’t stop him from trying.

Kazuya is the brawn to back up Victorique’s brains. Not to say that Kazuya is a musclebound jock because he comes off as quite intelligent. It’s just that everyone comes off less intelligent than Victorique. So this means his role is usually to be the physical partner and protector of Victorique. Kazuya is both fascinated and somewhat perplexed by Victorique. He definitely seems to be fond of Victorique but is also aggravated by her eccentric nature and caustic personality.

Victorique is a spiky, socially inept, observational genius. She is also very cute like a doll. I think I originally described her to Hisui as a meld between Nagi (from Hayate the Combat Butler) and Sherlock Holmes. She definitely solves things in that unimaginable Sherlockian way. As is proven when she solves a murder in under five minutes without even seeing the scene of the crime. She spends a good deal of her days cooped up in the library and we later learn she has seen virtually nothing of the outside world.

After reading the book myself I think Narutaki’s description is spot on. She is an odd paradox because she is amazingly insightful about certain things but amazingly naive about others. Almost all of her knowledge comes from books but she has almost no real world experience. This means despite her amazing intellect and ability to effortlessly solve logical puzzles, she is still fascinated by things such as traveling by carriage. She along with such habits as smoking a pipe give her an odd mixture of old soul and young girl.

gosick, detective, light novel, loli, victorique, kazuya

The developing relationship between these two looks to be a fun push and pull that will go on throughout the series. There was an ease of magic to them. This probably stems from their eccentricities which compliment one another. They are completely different and that makes them fit together like two puzzle pieces. We need both characters for this story to work. I was surprised that we the readers had missed their first meeting though. It is described briefly in the book and I can only assume it A. Happens in a later book, like a prequel, or B. Happened in one of the short story collections.

Apparently there are two types of books in the “Kazuya and Victorique” mystery franchise. The Gosick books are full novel-sized mysteries and the Gosicks, with an S, are short story collections. As fas as I can tell they meet in Gosicks I and it is made up of several interrelated mysteries. They both can be very naive but each of them is naive in a different way. They complement each other when they work together letting them cover the other’s weakness. The writer likes to do a little dance about whether or not Victorique has feelings for Kazuya. He will often play up some indication that Victorique does and then he will give us some reason that it meant nothing at all.

This was a mystery that at first I thought to be too simple. I thought I had it all figured out a little more than half way through the book. My personal preference for mysteries is to be mostly clueless, maybe to figure out who did it but not to understand all the circumstances surrounding it. I mean the writer kills off more than half the suspects in one fell swoop which left me wondering, why put them in at all? However, I was pleasantly surprised to be thrown the twist and not see it coming. The book made me assume a couple of things incorrectly, which is exactly what it should have done.

I figured out certain things before the big reveal but was wrong about other things. I had a little more insight into what was going to happen but that was mostly because Narutaki had inadvertently given me some tips when we were discussing the book before I read it. It’s certainly not the most complex mystery and it seems like it was supposed to be a longer story but I still feel it was well executed. We also learn of a larger, over-arcing mystery concerning Victorique. And from what I can tell this is a part of all the books. The next book looks to be dealing with this uber-mystery even more.

This is a light novel so obviously it is sparse on pictures but at the same time I felt there needed to be a few more, even if they were small pieces. For example, the writer constantly, what seems like every chapter, has to describe Victorique in glowing detail. As if Kazuya, nor the audience, hasn’t been along for this ride from the beginning. Even going so far as to take the exact same sentences from previous chapters. Why not just show us a picture to remind us, if you think we need reminding. So at times it seemed like they were in need of a better editor.

These in a light novel magazine not unlike The Sneaker. So if they ran a chapter a month they might have wanted to refresh the reader or tell new readers what Victorique looks like being she is one of the major selling points of the novel. But I am pretty sure that had they threw in a few more pictures as you mentioned, it would have saved them all that trouble.

This was a fun ride with two character that you can’t help but like. Combine that with a rich setting and a plot that has its twists, and you have won me over. I look forward to reading more of their adventures (if we are so lucky). I think this series could also be a nice foray for anyone who hasn’t jumped onto the light novel train yet. One thing I love about the detective formula is that it can continue for as long as you want it to.

gosick, detective, light novel, loli, victorique, kazuya