A Puzzling Objection: Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney

hisui_icon_4040 Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney always seemed like someone’s dream more than something that would get made. More the realm of fan fiction and comical videos than something you would actually play. Super Robot Wars, Project X Zone, Super Smash Bros., and Tekken X Street Fighter are all notable examples that while crossovers are not commonplace they are also hardly unheard of. So when the game was announced there was a good deal of buzz around the title. They are both melodramatic comedic puzzle games with a mystery structure and an anime style. The game play and mechanics  in both series was very different but it was fairly clear to most people with little effort both games could be combined in a way that let both of their strengths shine. All it would take is a smart story and a solid commitment to both sides of the crossover. There were a lot of things that could go wrong but it was equally feasible for the game to succeed big time.

And then we actually got Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney. I have read a bunch of reviews at this point and no one has hated the game. Overall all the reviews have been positive. But none of them have been glowing. If anything the general feeling has been underwhelming. It was fine but it could have been better. A lot of the complaints seem like nitpicks. They did not have enough cameos from fan favorite characters, mechanics from both main games could have blended more, the puzzles and court cases should have been tougher, hint coins made parts too easy, or the story could have been tighter were all sort of mediocre critics of the game I heard.

It is east to assume that this a the case of haters going to hate or that people have over inflated expectations that no game could live up to. But I don’t think that reaction is unwarranted. I think it is more people wandering through their reviews trying to touch on what made the game not live up to their dream but not being able to touch the core of their discontent. The thing is the sticking point might very well be at the heart of the story but to talk about that means spoiling a good deal of the plot.

So before we go to the rest of the review I’m going to give the game a quick one paragraph review and if you don’t want to be spoiled you can just read that and the decide if you want the game or not. But if you have played the game or don’t care about spoilers you can just continue past the next paragraph. I think that it the fairest way to do this.

I like the game but acknowledge its flaws. The game is decidedly more Professor Layton than Phoenix Wright in both storytelling and game play. Both halves get a chance to shine but Layton gets the first billing on the title for a reason. The puzzles for both halves is a bit more easy mode than what you are used to in the respective main series. If you are new to either half you won’t be over your head but if your and old hat don’t expect to be challenged most of the time. The story is fun but your mileage may vary on the twist during the last third. If you a fan of either series where is something to enjoy. The puzzles parts feel very Layton and I actually thought the Witch Trials were an interesting twist of the Ace Attorney formula. Just temper your expectations. This is more of good combination of two franchises than a golden child that is greater than the sums of its parts.

I might just be really happy that Maya has not been shipped off to the land of random offhanded mentions like she has in the recent games.

Continue reading

Dual Podcasts but One Destiny

Hisui was just on the OSMcast! to talk about Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Dual Destinies, the 5th game in the main Ace Attorney series. As always the first part of the OSMcast! discusses what everyone is doing, the middle part is the spoiler free discussion, and the end is for people who have played the game. Does Dual Destinies overcome the somewhat tarnished legacy of Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney? Can it surpass the high point that was Trials and Tribulations? Or is it more Justice for All than anything else? Listen in and find out.

This episode was recorded shortly before the DLC case Turnabout Reclaimed was released so while that case is mentioned in passing it is not part of the review. There might be a supplemental episode in the future about that.

OSMcast! Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Dual Destinies 11-25-2013

Ongoing Investigations: Case #230

narutaki_icon_4040 Helter Skelter by Kyoko Okazaki is as riveting as it is bizarre. Liliko a top model is as the height of her stardom which makes it a long way to fall as the physical abuse of her body begins to take its toll on her looks as well as her mind. She tries to escape her bitter loneliness with sex, drugs, degradation of her employees, revenge, and even more procedures which all lead her further and further down a spiral. Along side this is the morally depraved and unethical practices of the clinic she and others frequent as well as a commentary on our youth- and celebrity-obsessed culture.

Ms. Okazaki’s artwork hones in perfectly on the freakish extremes of beauty. Liliko looks unlike anyone else in the book, and all characters revere her beauty, but as a reader she looks so other worldly that it is often disturbing. This is double so when we meet her little sister who she has for the most part abandoned.

I hardly found Liliko sympathetic but she was fascinating, which very much felt like the point. Just as people get caught up in the rise and fall of celebrities, so too was I caught up with Liliko much like many of the characters in the book.  I simply had to know where it would all end.

I’m very much looking forward to Ms. Okazaki’s Pink coming out in English.


hisui_icon_4040 Kaoru Mori: Anything and Something is a special little book if you a fan of Kaoru Mori. I remember asking about this book a while back on Twitter and Lazerhosen‎ said it was a fun book for established fans. That that is a great assessment of the book. It remind me a lot of the Hayate no Gotoku! no Mae book for Kenjiro Hata. Anything and Something is a collection of one-shots, failed pilots, extras, sketches, promotional materials, and anything else that would not make a full book on its own.  These types books are a bit of a hard sell but they are invaluable resources to anyone who wishes to see the development of one of their favorite artists. Since materials in these books come from all over the manga-ka’s history you really can see their style develop over the years.

Since it is a Kaoru Mori there are of course lots of maid stories. Some pieces are fairly early in the career like the Miss Claire’s stories, some maid tales are utterly goofy like Welcome to the Mansion, and there are also stories that seem much more in the vein on Emma like Maudlin Baker. All the comics in that niche have an obsessive attention to detail about the costuming and history of the time with some bending of the era for story purposes. But unlike Emma and Shirley most of the stories have a whimsical nature that make them more suited for one shots than a dramatic story that can sustain several volumes.

There is also a good deal more cheesecake than you might normally expect from Kaoru Mori. I distinctly remember sexy scenes from Emma but they were mostly little treats more than the standard fare. So it is not like her main work does not show that she can do this sort of work. But stories like the Burrow Gentleman’s club, the Fellows cover story, as well as some of the promo art shows that she can do straight up sensual quite well. But she does one to keep an air of class about her sexy material. She can do sensual, sexual, and provocative without having to cross the line into vulgar. When she adds nudity it feels like it is part of the overall seduction of the material and not just the end goal.

There are also some modern tales which show that she is not bound to working in historical settings. It is interesting to see her stories in a more contemporary setting. A historical setting adds an element of the exotic even to an otherwise mundane story. So if you wish to examine Kaoru Mori’s storytelling without a layer of the past in between you and the story than these would be the tales to focus on.

The story that stands out the most is probably Sumire’s Flowers. The fact that it was written by Satoshi Fukushima explains why it feels so different from her normal work. There is darkness and cynicism that you just don’t see in her normal work. But it does show how her working with an author sort of transforms her artistry into something else. The art is mostly the same but the tone of the story makes it take on a very different life. It is interesting to see her work exist outside its normal boundaries.

There is also just a little section on maids and Agatha Christie. So there is even something for Kate in here. But besides that there are a good deal of little asides and story notes which give you a little insight into the author herself and the research she does for her stories.  It also has a good deal of material that would normally only see if you had bought the original magazines that ran her work.

But as I said in the beginning this book can be a hard sell. It really feels like a fan book more than anything official. A somewhat scatterbrained scrapbook of the works of an artist more than a guided tour of their career. If you have enjoyed Kaoru Mori’s work in the past you can get a good deal out of this book.  If you have not it can be an interesting way to experience her but it won’t have that same hook.

But everyone should at least try Emma so there is that fundamental truth to understand before anything else. Emma and A Bride’s Story are not for everyone but they are something that everyone into historical manga should at least sample as part of their education. If you enjoy either it is worth going back to Anything and Something and seeing where it all started.

The Ongoing Investigations are little peeks into what we are watching, reading, or playing outside of our main blog posts. We each pick three things without much rhyme or reason; they are just the most interesting things since the last OI.

Continue reading